Western Athletic Brands Face Deepening China Troubles, Wells Fargo Says

Major Western athletic brands are facing a worsening outlook in China, marked by weak demand, rising local competition, and aggressive promotional activity, according to a Wells Fargo analyst note. The bank's report summarizes a conversation with James Wong, the CEO of a prominent $900 million Chinese distributor and retailer of global brands.

Macro Headwinds and Competitive Pressures

The distributor outlined a challenging operating environment for Western brands. Consumer sentiment remains depressed due to job scarcity and high unemployment, leading to a drawdown in savings. This has been compounded by several factors impacting sales:

• Intensifying Competition: Local Chinese competitors are gaining ground by offering better value and shorter product lead times.
• Heavy Discounting: Promotions are being pulled forward, with significant discounting beginning in October ahead of major shopping events like 11.11 and 12.12.
• Elevated Inventory: Brands that have missed sales targets are now dealing with high inventory risk, forcing aggressive clearance sales.

Wong noted that high fixed costs from recent retail expansions have become a significant drag in the current declining sales environment. Extreme weather in the third quarter also disrupted business, pointing toward another challenging winter season.

Brand-Specific Performance Diverges

Ad

The distributor's own business reflects a stark divergence in brand performance. Wong’s Nike business sales trended down 20% in the third quarter, a sharp acceleration from a 10% decline in the second quarter, with the fourth quarter expected to be even worse. The closure of Nike's China online channel in July, which represented 20-25% of his sales, triggered clearance events with discounts of 70% to 80% off.

Deckers' HOKA brand is also seeing a significant slowdown, with sales tracking up just 2% to 3% in Q3, compared to over 20% growth last year. Wong cited "intensified hyper-competition" in the trail running market, where local brand KAILAS now holds over 50% market share. Lululemon's challenges reportedly stem from a lack of innovation in a crowded athleisure market, leading to increased promotional activity and reliance on outlets.

In contrast, some brands are navigating the market successfully. Adidas grew 16% in Q3 on its "China-for-China" strategy, while Salomon's sales trended up 21% on the back of successful fashion collaborations. On also saw growth accelerate to 15% in the third quarter.

Analyst Outlook

Based on these on-the-ground insights, Wells Fargo expects continued headwinds for Nike and Lululemon in the region. The firm also sees additional risk for Deckers as competition in its key categories intensifies. The report underscores the complex and rapidly evolving consumer landscape in China, where localization and value are becoming critical drivers of success.