New York Times Countersues EEOC, Alleges Retaliation Over Trump Coverage

The New York Times Co. has filed a countersuit against the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), alleging the agency's recent lawsuit over a hiring decision is a politically motivated act of retaliation. In a court filing on Friday, the newspaper accused the federal agency of a "bad faith use of its authority" in response to its coverage of the Trump administration.

Retaliation Allegations

The countersuit, filed in Manhattan federal court, seeks the dismissal of the EEOC's lawsuit from May. The Times is also asking for a declaration that the agency's actions violate its constitutional rights to free speech and due process. The newspaper's lawyers argued that the EEOC's lawsuit "poses a uniquely insidious threat to a free and independent press, and to our democracy."

An EEOC spokesperson stated that the agency does not comment on pending litigation, according to Reuters. The Times' filing directly connects the EEOC's legal action to President Trump's public criticism of the newspaper, which he has labeled a "true enemy of the people."

The Original Hiring Dispute

The EEOC's initial lawsuit was filed on behalf of Bryant Rousseau, a white male employee who was passed over for a promotion to deputy real estate editor in early 2025. The agency claimed the company's diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) goals led it to hire a less qualified multiracial woman for the position.

Ad

The New York Times has denied these claims, stating in its Friday filing that the selected candidate was better qualified and had more relevant experience than Rousseau. The company asserted that its aspirational diversity goals played no role in this specific hiring decision.

Broader Context on DEI Scrutiny

The legal battle comes amid a broader push by the EEOC to scrutinize corporate DEI policies. The commission is also reportedly investigating diversity initiatives at other major companies, including Nike and Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance, and has sued a Coca-Cola bottler over an event that excluded men.

This regulatory focus aligns with executive orders issued by President Trump aimed at ending DEI programs in government and the private sector. The conflict is further complicated by a separate, unrelated $15 billion defamation lawsuit President Trump has filed against The New York Times.