New York City to Mandate 'Click to Cancel' for Subscriptions, Ban Hidden Fees

New York City will implement new rules to ban businesses from using deceptive subscription models and hidden fees, requiring a straightforward cancellation process for consumers. City officials announced the new policy on Friday, positioning it as a significant step in consumer protection.

New 'Click to Cancel' Rule

The policy, which officials described as the first of its kind for a U.S. municipal government, will take effect on October 1. Its core components target two common consumer grievances:

• Subscription Traps: A "Click to Cancel" rule will apply to all automatic renewal and continuous service subscriptions. Businesses must clearly disclose the terms of the subscription and provide a simple, transparent cancellation method.
• Junk Fees: A separate rule will compel businesses to advertise the full, all-inclusive price of goods and services upfront. This includes all mandatory charges and fees that are often added later in the purchasing process.

Financial Impact and Enforcement

The move addresses what officials see as a significant financial burden on consumers. Citing consumer reports, the Mayor's office stated that hidden fees cost an average family of four an estimated $3,200 each year.

Ad

Businesses found in violation of the new rules will face significant penalties. According to the announcement, consequences include providing restitution to affected consumers and paying civil penalties that begin at $525 per violation. This creates a new compliance risk for companies operating subscription services or those with complex pricing structures in the city.

Policy Context

The city's initiative follows a failed attempt at the federal level. A national "Click to Cancel" rule introduced by the Biden administration was struck down by a federal appeals court last year before it could be implemented.

The policy aligns with the political platform of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who campaigned on a promise to make the city more affordable. The rules are being implemented jointly by the Mayor's office and the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.