JPMorgan Warns Oil Market's 'Temporary Disruption' View Is Faltering

JPMorgan's oil analysts are publicly voicing a growing concern among traders: the path to an endgame in the Middle East conflict, now over six months old, is becoming increasingly unpredictable. In a widely-circulated report, the bank’s analysts said their core assumption—that significant economic pressure would force a de-escalation—is being reset as those pressures have materialized without a corresponding diplomatic breakthrough.

Supply Risks Escalate Amid Infrastructure Attacks

The nature of energy risk in the region is expanding from restricted passage in maritime chokepoints to direct damage to alternative transport routes. This shift challenges the premise that supply disruptions would be temporary and quickly resolved.

Recent developments underscore the heightened risk:

• Houthi forces have reportedly captured the port of Mocha and several islands near the Bab el-Mandeb strait.
• Iran's Revolutionary Guard Navy claimed to have struck a tanker in the Strait of Hormuz on Sept. 17.
• Damage to Saudi Arabia's crucial East-West pipeline, which bypasses the Strait of Hormuz, has been confirmed. Three pump stations were hit, forcing a shutdown of the pipeline that previously carried 4 to 5 million barrels per day.

A Market Pricing for More Pain

Ad

Oil prices have retreated from recent highs on hopes of a partial supply recovery, but they remain significantly elevated compared to pre-conflict levels. Brent crude, which settled at $72.48 per barrel on Feb. 27, hit $108.75 on Sept. 15 before pulling back to around $103.77 by Sept. 18. This recent dip reflects expectations that Saudi Arabia may restore some pipeline capacity and increase ship-to-ship transfers, not a fundamental easing of geopolitical risk.

In their report, JPMorgan analysts led by Natasha Kaneva stated the market is "on edge." They estimate the fair value for oil in September is around $90 per barrel, but with prices trading significantly higher, they believe the market is pricing in a substantial risk premium. This premium reflects the potential for an additional 4 million barrels per day of supply to be lost, on top of the 10 million bpd already affected.

Wall Street Divided on Recovery Timeline

The uncertainty is creating a divergence in forecasts across Wall Street, with the primary disagreement centered on the timing and scale of a supply recovery. JPMorgan noted that if current supply disruptions persist, fourth-quarter and December oil prices could be $7 and $8 higher, respectively, than their current forecasts.

This contrasts with Citigroup's more optimistic call on Sept. 3 for Brent to fall to $70 in the fourth quarter, a forecast that preceded the latest pipeline damage. Goldman Sachs, meanwhile, raised its end-of-year and 2027 price forecasts on Sept. 7, projecting a more prolonged impact. The sustained pressure on energy prices complicates the macroeconomic outlook, making it harder for central banks and investors to forecast inflation and interest rate paths amid rising bond yields and recent monetary tightening by the Federal Reserve.