Citi Analysis Reveals How Stocks Typically Trade on Fed Rate Hike Days

An analysis by Citi using high-frequency data reveals that the first day of a Federal Reserve tightening cycle has not historically been a guaranteed negative for U.S. stocks, and a familiar intraday trading pattern often emerges during policy announcements.

The 'First Hike' Is Not Always Bearish

Contrary to some investor expectations, the initial rate hike of a tightening cycle has not been "uniformly bearish on the day," according to the research from Citi. The bank's analysts suggest this is because markets typically digest and price in much of the tightening risk before the policy action is officially announced.

Key findings from the bank's sample include:

• Across the seven previous "first hikes" examined, U.S. equities rose on four occasions.
• There was no consistent directional reaction across bonds, gold, or currencies on those specific days.

A Familiar Intraday Pattern

Citi's work points to a recurring sequence of events for equities on Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) decision days. The initial market reaction to the policy statement is often reversed during the subsequent press conference.

Ad

The typical pattern observed is:

• Initial Reaction: Equities frequently experience a positive move immediately following the 2:00 PM ET statement release.
• Press Conference Reversal: These gains are often unwound once the Fed Chair begins speaking, with the market typically ending the day slightly lower by an average of around 10 basis points.
• Directional Momentum: Citi wrote that initial gains post-statement are "typically unwound," while initial declines "tend to extend into the close."

Treasury Reactions and Recent Trends

The pattern for U.S. Treasuries is distinct, according to the analysis. The immediate "knee-jerk" move in yields upon the statement's release often marks the session's extreme, with yields then tending to mean-revert into the close. However, Citi notes these reactions can sometimes have a multi-day follow-through.

Looking at the past 12 FOMC meetings, the bank observed that equity returns have been mixed, with a more negative reaction around several recent decisions. This highlights that intraday moves often reflect the broader news flow and the nuanced tone of the press conference, rather than the rate decision alone.