Wall Street Misinterpreted Solar Tariff Impact, Climate Finance Expert Says

Wall Street’s initial reaction to the latest solar tariff announcement was a misread of the policy's fundamental impact, according to Matt Roling, a climate finance expert and professor at Northwestern's Kellogg School of Management.

In an interview with Investing.com, Roling noted that the market's response was indiscriminate, pointing out that even the stocks of companies negatively exposed to the tariffs saw initial gains. "Everyone's talking about which solar company won from Trump's tariffs. Nobody's talking about the fact that the losers' stocks went up too," he said.

Unpacking the Winners and Losers

According to Roling's analysis, the market failed to appreciate the nuances of the solar supply chain, which is critical to understanding the tariffs' effects. The policy specifically targets the silicon supply chain, creating distinct outcomes for different companies.

Key takeaways from his analysis include:

Ad

• First Solar (FSLR): A clear "winner by default." Roling explained that First Solar's panels are made from cadmium telluride, not silicon, exempting it from the new regulations. "While every other US panel maker has to prove where its polysilicon came from or risk a penalty, First Solar doesn't have to worry about it at all," he stated.
• Corning (GLW): An overlooked "quiet structural winner." Corning co-owns Hemlock Semiconductor, one of only two polysilicon plants in the U.S. Roling noted the muted share reaction is understandable because the financial benefit is diluted as it flows through a joint venture stake.
• Canadian Solar (CSIQ): The company most exposed to Chinese-linked sourcing. Roling expressed surprise at its positive stock movement, cautioning that its performance is influenced by a Shanghai-listed subsidiary and a one-time tariff refund.

Sector Noise vs. Fundamental Impact

Roling also pointed to several companies whose stock movements were driven by general market sentiment rather than the specifics of the tariff policy.

The initial stock price increase for installer Sunrun (RUN) was particularly surprising to Roling, as the company buys panels and is therefore exposed to higher costs. "The market cheered for a policy that taxes them," he remarked. Similarly, he characterized the initial moves in inverter manufacturers SolarEdge (SEDG) and Enphase (ENPH) as "sector beta," since their products are not part of the polysilicon supply chain targeted by the tariffs.