Stocks' Appeal Fades as Bond Yields Surge, Barclays Warns

Stocks have remained resilient during a global bond sell-off, but rising yields are making equities a less compelling investment choice, according to a note from Barclays on Friday. The bank warns that the argument for holding stocks over less risky assets is weakening significantly.

The 'TINA' Trade Fades

The core of the issue is the shrinking premium that investors receive for taking on the risk of owning stocks compared to bonds. According to Barclays strategist Emmanuel Cau, this extra return is now near its lowest level in decades. While stock market volatility has remained relatively contained, bond volatility has jumped to its highest point since March.

This dynamic undermines the long-standing “TINA” (There Is No Alternative) argument for owning equities. "The 'TINA' argument to own equities looks less compelling," Cau wrote. Although price-to-earnings ratios for stocks have declined, bonds have also become cheaper, offering more competitive returns.

A Balancing Act of Risks

Barclays notes that several factors are creating a complex market environment. Higher interest rates do not always hurt stocks, as they can reflect stronger economic growth and optimism around technologies like artificial intelligence. However, persistent headwinds remain.

Key risks highlighted by the bank include:

Ad

• Oil prices remaining above $100 a barrel.
• Major central banks continuing to raise interest rates.
• Geopolitical uncertainty, such as the elusive de-escalation between the U.S. and Iran.

"The key question is where is the breaking point?" Cau wrote. Barclays expects markets to remain on edge at least until the third-quarter earnings season provides more clarity.

Barclays' Strategic Positioning

Despite the mounting pressures, Barclays said it remains overweight equities relative to bonds. The bank cited resilient growth, positive earnings momentum, and the economy's lower sensitivity to higher rates as reasons for its stance. However, it acknowledged that the "balance of risks has become less favorable."

In Europe, the bank sees a mixed picture, with headwinds from higher oil prices and fears of disruption from U.S. technology. In response, Barclays has adjusted its European portfolio, recently adding telecoms and insurers while reducing exposure to materials and luxury goods. It continues to favor banks and companies positioned to benefit from capital spending.