Citi Downgrades Abercrombie & Fitch to Neutral on Valuation After 36% Rally

Citi has downgraded Abercrombie & Fitch (NYSE: ANF) to Neutral from a Buy rating, citing the stock's sharp rally following strong quarterly results which has created a more balanced risk/reward profile for investors.

Valuation Drives Rating Change

In a note to clients on Thursday, Citi analyst Paul Lejuez stressed that the downgrade was a valuation call and not a reflection of the company's fundamentals. The move follows a +36% surge in ANF's stock price in a single day after its recent earnings report.

Lejuez wrote that with the stock's significant appreciation, there is now only 6% potential upside to the bank's new price target. "We view the risk/reward as balanced," the analyst stated, explaining the rationale for moving to the sidelines.

Fundamentals Underpin Higher Price Target

Despite the rating change, Citi raised its price target on Abercrombie & Fitch to $156 from a previous $135. The bank pointed to an "all-around impressive" second quarter and "very encouraging" guidance for the third quarter and second half of the year.

Key positive factors highlighted by the firm include:

Ad

• Second-quarter results that beat expectations on both sales and gross margin.
• An acceleration in sales at the Hollister brand in the third quarter to date.
• Continued strong momentum for the Abercrombie brand.
• An earlier-than-expected recovery in the EMEA region.

Citi also sees potential upside to the company's second-half guidance for average unit retail (AUR), which currently assumes only modest growth.

Revised Estimates

Reflecting the retailer's strong performance, Citi significantly increased its earnings per share (EPS) estimates. The bank's forecast for fiscal 2026 now stands at $13.64, up from $11.10, and its fiscal 2027 estimate was lifted to $13.80 from $12.65.

For the current year, Citi's model projects 5.2% sales growth for the company, with an estimated EBIT margin of 14.9%.