Barclays Upgrades CubeSmart, Downgrades Public Storage on Shifting Valuations

Barclays has revised its stance on key players in the U.S. self-storage sector, upgrading CubeSmart (NYSE: CUBE) to Overweight while downgrading Public Storage (NYSE: PSA) to Equal Weight. The brokerage said the ratings changes were driven by a shift in relative valuations following divergent stock performances year-to-date.

Valuation Drives Analyst Actions

The core of Barclays' decision rests on the recent performance of the two real estate investment trusts (REITs). Public Storage's strong outperformance in the market has reduced its potential for further upside, according to the analysts, prompting the downgrade. In contrast, CubeSmart's weaker performance has created a more attractive entry point.

Barclays outlined its updated price targets and rationale:

• CubeSmart (CUBE): Upgraded to Overweight from Equal Weight, with the price target raised to $46 from $45. Analysts cited the company's urban-focused portfolio, strong pricing power, and improving move-in trends as key strengths.
• Public Storage (PSA): Downgraded to Equal Weight from Overweight, with the price target unchanged at $349. The firm still expects healthy growth but sees less upside potential at the stock's current valuation.

Sector Enters Early Recovery

Ad

These rating changes come as Barclays sees the U.S. self-storage sector entering the initial phases of a recovery. The firm attributes this positive outlook to an easing of new supply, which is expected to support gradual improvements in occupancy rates, rental pricing, and funds-from-operations (FFO) growth for major operators.

However, Barclays cautioned that the recovery is likely to be gradual. Elevated mortgage rates are expected to limit housing turnover, a key driver of demand for self-storage services, thereby tempering the pace of the rebound.

Extra Space Storage Remains Top-Rated

Barclays maintained its Overweight rating on Extra Space Storage (NYSE: EXR) and increased its price target to $172 from $170. The brokerage highlighted the company's strong move-in rates, easing pricing headwinds, and growth potential from its third-party management platform and ancillary businesses as reasons for its continued positive outlook.