Baird Downgrades Nike, Adidas, and Dick's Citing Q4 Consumer Risks

Baird has adopted a more cautious stance on the apparel, footwear, and fitness sector, downgrading several industry leaders due to what it sees as rising risks for the fourth quarter. The investment firm cited a challenging macroeconomic environment and potential weakness in consumer spending for the ratings changes.

Sweeping Ratings Changes

In a note to clients, Baird analyst Jonathan Komp lowered his ratings for several prominent companies to Neutral. The downgrades include:

• Nike (NKE)
• Adidas (ADSGn)
• Dick's Sporting Goods (DKS)
• VF Corp (VFC)
• Rocky Brands (RCKY)

Additionally, the firm identified Under Armour (UAA) and Canada Goose (GOOS) as bearish "fresh picks" through mid-November, signaling a short-term negative outlook. Komp noted that the group's poor performance this year, with a median stock decline of 17% versus a 12% gain for the S&P 500, has challenged the firm's previous recovery thesis.

Macro Headwinds Pressure Consumers

Ad

Baird's revised outlook is driven by several macroeconomic factors that could dampen consumer demand. The firm highlighted concerns that choppy monthly spending data and more cautious commentary from retailers suggest that lower- and middle-income consumers are feeling financial pressure.

Key headwinds cited by the analyst include WTI crude oil prices at or above $100 a barrel, 10-year Treasury yields approaching 5%, and an uptick in promotional activity. Baird also warned that consensus earnings estimates for periods beyond the third quarter appear aggressive for some companies, particularly Canada Goose, Under Armour, and VF Corp.

Selective Outlook

While broadly cautious, Baird trimmed its list of Outperform-rated stocks to a smaller group of its "highest-conviction ideas." These include Amer Sports (AS), On Holding (ONON), Kontoor Brands (KTB), Wolverine World Wide (WWW), Boot Barn (BOOT), and Crocs (CROX).

The analyst acknowledged that many stocks in the sector appear inexpensive on a valuation basis and possess significant share buyback capacity. However, Baird concluded that these positive factors may not be enough to drive share prices higher over the next few months if concerns about oil prices and inflation persist.