Macy's Shares Fall Despite Q2 Earnings Beat as Weak Guidance Clouds Outlook

Macy's Inc. (NYSE: M) reported second-quarter earnings that significantly beat analyst expectations, but shares fell as investors focused on the quality of the results and a weak forecast for the upcoming quarter.

Shares of the retailer traded down 3.81% to $20.69 on September 10 after the company revealed that a one-time tariff refund contributed heavily to its profit beat, while its guidance pointed to an adjusted loss in the third quarter.

Earnings Quality in Focus

Macy's posted strong headline numbers for its second quarter, according to its latest earnings report. However, the underlying details raised concerns about sustainable momentum.

• Adjusted EPS: $0.63, well ahead of the consensus estimate of $0.35.
• Revenue: $4.90 billion, compared to expectations of $4.78 billion.
• Comparable Sales: Increased 2.7%, marking the fifth straight quarter of growth.

Despite these figures, the company disclosed that approximately $0.23 per share of its earnings came from tariff refunds, a non-recurring benefit. Management noted that most of these funds would be reinvested into marketing and store initiatives, with only about $0.05 per share expected to reach the bottom line.

Weak Guidance and Uneven Performance

Ad

While Macy's raised its full-year guidance for adjusted EPS to a range of $2.15–$2.35, its third-quarter outlook disappointed the market. The company guided for an adjusted loss of $0.19 to $0.23 per share on revenue between $4.65 billion and $4.70 billion.

The retailer's growth was also uneven across its brands. The company's premium banners were the primary growth drivers, with comparable sales at Bloomingdale’s rising 11.3% and at Bluemercury by 6.2%. The core Macy's nameplate saw more modest growth of 1.1%, highlighting ongoing challenges in its main business line.

What Investors Are Watching

Looking ahead, investors will be focused on whether Macy's can generate profit without temporary tailwinds. The company's third-quarter earnings, due November 12, will be a critical test of its operational strength against a difficult prior-year comparison.

Key catalysts include holiday season execution, particularly around inventory and promotional discipline, and the continued performance of its premium brands. Investors will also monitor the progress of the "Reimagine 200" store modernization program, which management said continues to outperform, to see if it can become a repeatable driver of sales and margin improvement.