HSBC Downgrades IBM to 'Reduce,' Proposing 'Synthetic' Peer Portfolio for Better Value

HSBC downgraded International Business Machines (IBM) to Reduce from Hold on Tuesday, arguing that a custom-built portfolio of the tech giant's peers offers superior value and earnings growth. The bank also cut its price target on IBM stock to $191 from $231, implying significant downside from current levels.

The 'Synthetic IBM' Thesis

In a note to investors, HSBC analyst Abhishek Shukla detailed the construction of a "synthetic IBM" designed to replicate the company's exposure to various tech subsectors. This basket includes shares of SAP, Accenture, HP, and IonQ.

The bank's analysis suggests that for an investment equal to IBM's share price of $287.56, this peer portfolio would deliver significantly higher returns. Key projections from the note include:

• IBM Projected 2030 EPS: $16.59 (non-GAAP)
• 'Synthetic' Portfolio Projected 2030 EPS: $23.15
• The Difference: A 40% higher earnings potential for the peer basket with similar sector exposure.

Valuation and Competitive Pressures

Ad

HSBC's downgrade is also rooted in concerns over IBM's valuation and competitive landscape. The bank noted that IBM trades at 22.0 times its estimated 2027 non-GAAP price-to-earnings ratio, a premium to the sector median of 16.9 times, despite having slower expected earnings growth.

Furthermore, the report highlighted specific competitive threats. In quantum computing, HSBC stated that IonQ "may be stealing a march over IBM's quantum business," citing IonQ's nearly $600 million in new orders over the past five quarters compared to IBM's $100 million.

Growth Sustainability Concerns

HSBC also questioned the quality of IBM's growth, suggesting it is "less sustainable as it is dependent upon continued cost cutting" when compared to peers like SAP and Accenture. While the bank projects IBM's software non-GAAP EBIT to grow at a compound annual rate of 10.6% through 2030, it noted this is driven by weaker revenue growth.

The new $191 price target from HSBC implies a potential downside of 33.6% from IBM's current trading levels, reflecting the bank's conviction that investors can find better opportunities in a combination of its competitors.