Carnival Stock Selloff 'Overdone,' Presents Buying Opportunity: Stifel

Analysts at Stifel are advising investors to buy Carnival Corp. (CCL) shares ahead of the cruise operator's third-quarter results, arguing that a recent sharp decline in the stock's value has created a compelling buying opportunity.

An 'Overreaction' to Market Headwinds

In a note to clients, Stifel analyst Steven Wieczynski described the recent pullback in Carnival's stock as another "overreaction." The firm believes that investor fears regarding Caribbean pricing, elevated fuel costs, and overall demand have been more than factored into the current share price.

Over the last six weeks, Carnival's shares have fallen approximately 27%, a period during which the S&P 500 was flat and global fuel prices rose by about 24%, according to the Stifel report. The analysis suggests this steep underperformance is disproportionate to the underlying risks.

Quantifying the Impact

While Stifel acknowledges that intensified competition in the Caribbean could pressure near-term pricing, it estimates the potential impact to be modest. The firm projects a hit of just 50 to 75 basis points of yield.

Ad

"Not sure that we can sit here and say that 50bps-75bps of yield impact should equate to a ~25% drop in the equity value," Wieczynski wrote. The note also highlighted Carnival's strong booking position, stating the company was already 93% booked for fiscal 2026 as of June.

Forward-Looking Catalysts

Stifel anticipates that positive commentary on 2027 booking trends during Carnival's upcoming earnings call on September 29 could serve as a near-term catalyst for the stock. The firm also stated that Carnival's long-term financial targets for 2029 remain "massively underappreciated" by the market.

The analysts added that any potential stock weakness in competitors like Royal Caribbean (RCL) or Viking (VIK) following Carnival's report would also represent a buying opportunity, noting those operators are better positioned.