UK Secrecy on Apple Data Access Demand Challenged as 'Farcical' in Court

The U.K. government's refusal to confirm or deny its demand for access to encrypted Apple user data was labeled 'farcical' by a lawyer for civil rights groups in a London tribunal on Thursday, escalating a legal battle with significant implications for user privacy and corporate responsibility.

The case centers on a secret order, known as a Technical Capability Notice (TCN), which civil rights groups and Apple (AAPL) allege the government issued to compel the company to create a “back door” into its encrypted cloud services.

Court Challenges Government Secrecy

At a hearing before the U.K.'s specialist Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPT), lawyers for both Apple and campaign groups Privacy International and Liberty challenged the government's long-standing policy of “neither confirm nor deny” (NCND) on national security matters.

Ben Jaffey, a lawyer representing the campaign groups, argued the government's stance has "become farcical," stating that "the horse has long bolted." He noted that U.S. politicians and unnamed U.K. government sources have already publicly referenced the order, rendering the secrecy policy an affront to open justice that prevents meaningful public debate.

Government Cites National Security

Ad

The British government's lawyer, Neil Sheldon, defended the NCND policy, arguing that any deviation would create a national security risk. He told the tribunal that confirming which tech operators are subject to TCNs "would provide material assistance to hostile actors."

According to the government's position, allowing adversaries to build a picture of the U.K.'s surveillance capabilities would undermine national security efforts. The tribunal will issue a ruling on the NCND policy at a later date, with a full hearing on the underlying TCN demand not expected until next year.

Background of the Dispute

The legal challenge stems from a TCN reportedly issued in July of last year, which applied specifically to Apple's customers in the United Kingdom. This followed an earlier, broader notice targeting both U.S. and British citizens' data that was withdrawn after negotiations with the U.S. government.

In response to the U.K.'s demands, Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection feature for U.K. users in February of last year. The company has consistently maintained that creating a backdoor for one government would weaken security for all users by creating a vulnerability that could be exploited by hackers or hostile states.