Nestlé Outperforms Unilever by 16%, but Valuation Metrics Now Favor Rival

An analysis of consumer staples giants Nestlé and Unilever reveals a stark divergence in stock performance over the past year, with Nestlé outperforming its rival by nearly 16 percentage points. However, a closer look at valuation metrics suggests Unilever now presents a more compelling case on value, according to data from Investing.com.

Valuation Snapshot

On a historical basis, Unilever appears to be the more attractively priced stock. The company's valuation metrics show a distinct advantage on a trailing basis, though this narrows considerably when looking at future earnings expectations.

• Unilever (UL): Trades at a trailing price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 21.3x and a forward P/E of 17.0x.
• Nestlé (NESN): Trades at a higher trailing P/E of 26.9x and a forward P/E of 17.2x.

While Unilever’s advantage comes from its lower trailing multiple, the near-identical forward valuations indicate that investors expect similar earnings performance ahead. According to fair-value models cited by Investing.com, Unilever has a potential upside of 10.8%, compared to 6.6% for Nestlé as of September 4, 2026.

Earnings Quality and Performance

Ad

Nestlé’s recent stock outperformance is supported by a stronger long-term revenue trend, though both companies reported sales declines in 2025. Nestlé’s revenue grew from $95.88 billion in 2021 to $113.47 billion in 2025, despite a 2.0% decline that year. Unilever’s revenue was mostly flat over the same period, with a sharper 3.8% drop in 2025.

Notably, gross margins for both companies converged at approximately 46% in 2025, erasing a historical advantage for Nestlé. Unilever reported a higher Return on Equity (ROE) of 32.9% versus Nestlé’s 25.6%, which supports its valuation case but can also be an indicator of greater financial leverage.

Market Implications

The significant 15.9 percentage point performance gap over the last year suggests that the popular long-Nestlé, short-Unilever pair trade has already captured a substantial move. The investment thesis may now be shifting from one of clear momentum to a question of relative value.

With forward P/E ratios closely aligned, the decision for investors now hinges on whether Unilever's cheaper trailing valuation and higher ROE are compelling enough to close the performance gap. Nestlé currently offers a higher dividend yield at 4.0% compared to Unilever's 3.3%, a factor that income-focused investors may consider.