JPMorgan Models Fed Scenarios, Sees 50% Chance of 'Hawkish Hold'

JPMorgan Chase & Co. has mapped out five potential scenarios for the Federal Reserve's highly anticipated interest rate decision, providing clients with a playbook for potential market reactions amid heightened uncertainty. The bank's analysis highlights a significant, albeit minority, chance of a surprise rate hike that could trigger a sharp equity sell-off.

Scenarios and Market Impact

Analysts at JPMorgan’s U.S. Market Intelligence desk have assigned probabilities to several outcomes. Their baseline forecast is a “hawkish hold,” which they view as the most likely scenario with a 50% probability.

• In this case, the Fed would keep rates steady but issue stern warnings on inflation, likely causing the S&P 500 to move within a tight range of a 0.25% gain to a 0.5% loss.
• A “dovish hold,” with a 28% probability, could spark a relief rally, pushing the S&P 500 up by as much as 1%.
• A surprise quarter-point rate hike is assigned a 20% probability and would be a significant blow to stocks, potentially causing a 1.5% to 2% decline in the S&P 500. The note warns that high-growth technology stocks could suffer even steeper losses.
• An extreme 50-basis-point hike is seen as a tail risk with only a 1% chance, but it could trigger a market plunge of 2% to 4%.

Expert Commentary

While the trading desk laid out possibilities, JPMorgan's chief U.S. economist, Michael Feroli, expects the Fed will ultimately hold rates steady. However, Feroli anticipates a fractured vote, predicting at least two hawkish dissents from officials pushing for an immediate rate increase.

Ad

This internal division underscores the contentious nature of the upcoming decision as policymakers weigh strong labor data against persistent inflation.

Market Pricing and Volatility

Derivative markets are reflecting the anxiety, pricing in a 36% chance of a surprise rate increase, according to the source material. Options expiring on the day of the announcement are positioned for significant volatility, implying a swift 0.8% swing in the S&P 500.

Despite the market's jitters, JPMorgan's market intelligence team suggested that the true probability of a hike may be lower than traders expect, pegging it at less than 30%. The desk noted that if the central bank intended to shock markets with a hike, an earlier opportunity this summer might have been more logical.