Best Buy Shares Fall Despite Earnings Beat as Operating Costs Surge

Best Buy (BBY) reported second-quarter earnings that surpassed analyst expectations and raised its full-year profit forecast, yet its shares declined as investors focused on a sharp, unexpected rise in operating costs. The company's stock fell 4.8% to $83.23 in afternoon trading following the release.

Earnings Beat Marred by Expense Concerns

For its second fiscal quarter of 2027, Best Buy posted adjusted earnings per share of $1.47, beating the consensus estimate of $1.35. Revenue also topped forecasts, coming in at $9.78 billion. In a sign of confidence, the company lifted its full-year EPS guidance to a range of $6.70 to $6.90, up from a consensus of $6.62.

Despite the positive headline figures, the market reacted negatively to a surge in Selling, General & Administrative (SG&A) expenses, which ballooned by $130 million year-over-year, far exceeding the company's initial guidance of a $30 million increase. This spending, driven by higher incentive compensation and investments in its marketplace and advertising arms, compressed the company's adjusted operating income rate to 4.3%, disappointing some investors.

Bright Spots in Diversification

Beyond the cost concerns, Best Buy's report highlighted successful efforts to diversify its revenue streams. The company is seeing growth in key categories outside of its core computing business, which faces tougher comparisons ahead.

Ad

Key growth areas included:

• Home Theater: Posted its highest sales growth since the second quarter of fiscal 2022.
• Mobile Phones: Grew for the fourth consecutive quarter.
• Best Buy Business: The commercial division surged 21% year-over-year and now represents over $1.1 billion in annual revenue.
• Marketplace: Gross merchandise volume (GMV) from its third-party marketplace reached approximately $300 million in the quarter, prompting the company to raise its full-year target for the high-margin segment to $1.3 billion.

Headwinds and Leadership Transition

The company's computing segment presented a mixed picture, with average selling prices rising by a mid-teens percentage while unit sales fell by high single digits. Management cautioned that this category faces more challenging comparisons in the second half of the year as the sales boost from the Windows 10 upgrade cycle subsides.

Adding to the uncertainty is a planned leadership transition. Jason Bonfig is set to take over as CEO on November 1, with Anne Bramman joining as the new CFO. The executive changes come as the company navigates a complex retail environment and executes its strategic shift toward higher-margin services and marketplace sales.