S&P 500 Record High Masks Widespread Declines in Majority of Stocks

Major U.S. stock indices closed near record levels on Monday, but the headline numbers conceal a significant downturn across the majority of the market. While the S&P 500 gained 0.70% to close at 7,676.80, a vast number of its constituent stocks are trading well below their recent peaks, signaling a lack of broad market participation.

A Tale of Two Markets

Beneath the surface of the index's strength, a starkly different picture emerges. Approximately 82% of S&P 500 member stocks were trading at least 10% below their own highs, with about 60% down 20% or more, placing them in bear market territory. This data was highlighted in an Oct. 26 report from TheStreet, citing Ted Thatcher, founder of Bright Lake Wealth Management.

This divergence indicates that the market's recent rally has been driven by a very narrow group of companies. According to Thatcher, leadership since the March 30 lows has come from roughly 10 firms, most of which are associated with the artificial intelligence sector. This has created a bifurcated market where a handful of megacaps are pulling the averages higher while most other stocks are experiencing a slow, persistent sell-off.

Valuation and Macroeconomic Pressures

For investors looking for opportunities in beaten-down stocks, the current environment requires careful analysis to distinguish between genuine discounts and "value traps." A lower price alone is not a sufficient signal, as two primary factors can justify much of the recent declines.

Ad

First, higher interest rates mechanically reduce the present value of future corporate earnings. With the Federal Reserve's target range at 3.75% to 4.00% and the 10-year Treasury yield near 4.98% as of Monday, the higher discount rate makes stocks inherently less valuable. Second, a deteriorating earnings outlook for a specific company can lead to what is known as a value trap—a stock that appears cheap but continues to fall as its underlying business weakens.

Scrutinizing the Multiples

Even among market leaders, headline valuation metrics can be misleading. For example, Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL) appeared to trade at a modest 16 times its 2026 earnings estimates. However, according to figures published by TheStreet, this multiple includes a $6.26-per-share one-time investment revaluation benefit. Excluding this item, the stock's price-to-earnings ratio is closer to 23, presenting a much different valuation case.

Similarly, Amazon's (NASDAQ:AMZN) valuation is impacted by a $53.4 billion gain on its stake in Anthropic. Once adjusted for this, its 2026 earnings multiple rises to approximately 27. These examples underscore the importance of scrutinizing financial statements beyond simple screening metrics to understand a company's true valuation in a market characterized by narrow leadership and widespread weakness.