Pennsylvania Senate Election Poses Key Regulatory Risk for Utility Stocks, Mizuho Warns

The upcoming Pennsylvania statehouse elections could be a disruptive event for the state's utility sector, with a potential shift in political power carrying significant regulatory implications, according to a new analysis from Mizuho. The firm is advising investors to monitor the race for the Pennsylvania Senate, where a Democratic victory could give Governor Shapiro the leverage to advance a more aggressive policy agenda.

High Stakes in Harrisburg

For Democrats to gain control of the State Senate for the first time since 1978, the party must flip three seats and retain a Lancaster seat won by a narrow 526-vote margin in a 2025 special election. Mizuho notes that this presents an "uphill battle" due to gerrymandered districts, even as Governor Shapiro holds a substantial polling lead.

A Democratic victory would create a "Democratic trifecta"—control of the governorship, House, and Senate. According to Mizuho, this would shift the legislative debate from *whether* new affordability legislation passes to *how far* Governor Shapiro is willing to push the policy framework for utilities.

Potential Policy Overhaul

Investors are focused on potential changes to how utilities are compensated. Mizuho points to Governor Shapiro's stated goals, outlined in an April letter to utility CEOs, which include lowering equity ratios, reducing the allowed Return on Equity (ROE), and demanding more clarity on capital expenditure plans.

Ad

A previous bill, HB 2224, serves as a potential blueprint for future legislation. The bill, which proposed a default ROE set at the 10-year Treasury yield plus 2%, passed unanimously in the House but did not advance in the Republican-controlled Senate. A change in Senate leadership could revive this or similar measures.

Commission Control in the Balance

The composition of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PUC), the state's primary regulator, is also in play. The commission is currently deadlocked with a 2-2 Republican-Democrat split following the end of Commissioner Zerfuss's term on September 30.

Mizuho anticipates Governor Shapiro will nominate a new member in 2027, with the political leaning of the nominee likely dependent on the election's outcome. Furthermore, with Commissioner John Coleman's seat expiring in April 2027, the governor could have the opportunity to appoint two new members, potentially reshaping the commission's direction for years to come.