Hershey Wins Dismissal of Lawsuit Over Reese's Halloween Pumpkin Designs

A federal judge has dismissed a proposed class-action lawsuit against The Hershey Company that claimed the confectioner misled consumers with its packaging for Halloween-themed Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins. The suit alleged the candy's packaging falsely depicted decorative carvings that were absent on the actual product.

Details of the Ruling

U.S. District Judge Melissa Damian in Miami ruled that the two Florida residents leading the case lacked the legal standing to sue. The plaintiffs, Nathan Vidal and Eduardo Granados, argued they overpaid for the candy, seeking the "novelty" value of the "cool and beautiful carved-out designs" shown on the wrapper, according to court filings.

In her decision, Judge Damian wrote that the plaintiffs' only injury was their "subjective disappointment." The judge noted that the lawsuit did not allege the candy was defective or worthless, and therefore the plaintiffs had not lost all economic value from their purchase.

The court also rejected the claim that the plaintiffs overpaid by up to 25%, as they could not prove a direct price comparison between their purchase at a Publix supermarket and prices at other retailers cited in their complaint, such as Target and Walmart.

Hershey's Defense

Ad

In its motion to dismiss the lawsuit, Hershey argued that its packaging included a disclaimer stating the depicted carvings were a "decorating suggestion." The company contended that an objectively reasonable consumer would not believe the candy came pre-carved with a face.

Hershey's legal filings asserted that the plaintiffs "got what they bargained for--delicious candy." The company has declined to comment further on the litigation, as is its policy.

Next Steps

This was the second time the lawsuit has been dismissed. A lawyer for the plaintiffs, James Kelly, told Reuters that his clients were disappointed with the outcome and are planning to appeal the decision. The case highlights ongoing legal scrutiny over product packaging and consumer expectations.

The ruling comes as Hershey has already rolled out more than 20 Halloween-themed products for the upcoming holiday season, including the Reese's pumpkins at the center of the dispute.