Hawaiian Electric Stock Presents Stark Contrast Between Value and Distress

Hawaiian Electric Industries (HE) stock is caught between classic value metrics and acute signs of financial distress, creating a deeply polarized outlook for the utility. While a valuation model based on Benjamin Graham's formula suggests a potential upside of over 30%, the company's Altman Z-Score of 0.6 signals a high risk of default, according to an analysis by Investing.com.

A Tale of Two Valuations

On the surface, Hawaiian Electric exhibits traits of an undervalued company. As of September 3, its stock traded at $11.09, while a Ben Graham-based intrinsic value calculation pegged it at $14.39. This model, however, is backward-looking and may not fully account for the company's recent challenges, including an earnings-per-share figure that collapsed to -$11.24 in fiscal 2024 due to wildfire-related write-downs.

The market appears to be taking a more cautious approach. The current share price is closely aligned with the company's tangible book value and reflects a simple calculation: the value of its core utility business minus the considerable weight of its legal obligations. The stock is currently trading just above its book value per share of approximately $10.17, with analysts' consensus price target hovering around $12.00.

Red Flags on the Balance Sheet

The most significant warning sign is the company's Altman Z-Score of 0.6, a figure well below the 1.8 threshold that indicates financial distress. This metric, designed to predict bankruptcy risk, suggests the utility is in a precarious financial position. Several other indicators support this view:

Ad

• Unfunded Liabilities: The company faces $1.44 billion in remaining unfunded wildfire settlement payments.
• Cash Burn: Its free cash flow yield stands at a deeply negative -29.5%.
• High Leverage: Debt-to-equity is at 158.9%, an elevated level for a regulated utility.
• Dividend: The dividend remains suspended, removing a key support for utility stock valuations.

The Path to Recovery vs. Ongoing Risks

Despite the severe financial pressure, a potential recovery path exists. The company has secured recent credit upgrades from S&P and Moody's, and it has approved rate increases totaling $169.8 million set to take effect in 2027 and 2028. Furthermore, its regulated rate base is projected to grow 27% by 2028, which could restore its earnings power.

However, significant hurdles remain. The company has not yet detailed a financing plan for its multi-billion dollar liabilities, and a recent earnings miss in the second quarter of 2026 shows the recovery is slower than anticipated. Management has labeled 2026 a "transitional year," while unbudgeted costs from the recent Hurricane Lala add another layer of financial strain.