Software Stocks Bifurcate on Dueling AI and M&A Narratives

The software sector is currently defined by a tale of two distinct narratives—rapid AI-driven growth and deep M&A value—which has bifurcated stocks into clear cohorts for investors to navigate. While fears that artificial intelligence would cannibalize the industry have largely subsided, a clear division has emerged between companies priced for AI perfection and those seen as undervalued fundamental or M&A plays.

A Sector Divided

Recent earnings reports have shifted the market narrative, with companies like Salesforce and CrowdStrike demonstrating in late August that AI can be a significant revenue driver. This performance has created a clear split in valuations, sorting companies into three primary groups:

• AI Monetization Leaders: This cohort includes firms like CrowdStrike (CRWD) and Palo Alto Networks (PANW). While they have delivered stellar year-to-date returns of over 100%, their valuations appear stretched, with astronomical price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios and negative fair-value upside, according to screener data.
• Structural Undervaluation Plays: Legacy giants such as Salesforce (CRM) and Oracle (ORCL) fall into this category. They trade at more conventional P/E multiples in the low 20s and, based on the same data, present potential fair-value upside of over 30%, making a case based on fundamentals.
• Speculative M&A Targets: A third group consists of companies whose primary investment thesis is a potential acquisition. Analysts at Truist have published lists of potential targets, whose stock movements are more likely to be driven by deal speculation and activist pressure than by quarterly earnings.

Private Equity Sets a Valuation Floor

Merger and acquisition activity is providing a structural support for the sector's valuations. Talks in late August between Workday and private equity firm Silver Lake reportedly established a valuation floor for software M&A at approximately 15x free cash flow (FCF). This signal that private equity sees public market multiples as mispriced sent immediate ripples through the market, boosting European software stocks like Nemetschek and Sage in sympathy.

Ad

Salesforce itself exemplifies the complex dynamics at play, viewed as both a potential M&A target due to its valuation and an active acquirer. The company has made several acquisitions in 2026, including Listen Labs and Fin/Intercom, to integrate agentic AI capabilities into its platform.

Investor Outlook

A May 2026 note from Goldman Sachs offers a key perspective, cautioning that low valuation alone is not a sufficient catalyst. The bank stated that AI-related disclosures would only be rewarded by the market if investors perceive the new revenue as "additive to WholeCo growth."

This framework suggests that conflating the different software narratives can lead to portfolio construction errors. For investors, the challenge is to distinguish between high-flying growth stories that are already fully priced and fundamentally sound companies where a potential M&A floor provides downside protection while a re-rating in valuation offers a path to upside.