Story

Zillow Downgraded by Bernstein on Disappointing Financial Guidance

ENTHMSVIIDZHZH-TWJAKOHI
Aug 6, 20262 min read
Zillow Downgraded by Bernstein on Disappointing Financial Guidance
Text size
Background

Bernstein downgraded Zillow Group to Market-Perform from Outperform on Thursday, citing a loss of confidence in its investment thesis after the real estate platform issued disappointing second-quarter results and forward guidance. The firm also significantly reduced its price target on the company's stock to $38 from $50.

Thesis Unravels on Weak Outlook

In a note to investors, Bernstein analyst Nikhil Devnani stated the firm was "throwing in the towel" on its bullish call, admitting it "got this one painfully wrong." The downgrade stems from a weakened conviction in Zillow's fundamental growth story, which was previously based on expected market share gains and significant operating leverage from its revenue model transition.

This confidence was eroded by Zillow's weak second-half financial forecast. The company guided for its core Residential segment to experience no year-over-year growth in the third quarter, a key factor in the reassessment. Bernstein also lowered its EBITDA run-rate estimate for Zillow by 10%.

Headwinds in Core Business

Bernstein observed that Zillow's market share gains, excluding its mortgage business, appear to be compressing. The firm attributed this slowdown to several factors:

Sample IUX Markets – In-articleAd
  • A shift in revenue accruing to the Mortgage segment over the core Residential business.
  • A time lag in the recognition of mortgage-related revenue.
  • Increasing business seasonality.

While these headwinds are expected to lessen by the second half of 2027, Bernstein cautioned they could still restrain Residential revenue growth throughout the year. The firm noted that the subdued growth in Zillow's primary profit center makes it challenging to underwrite above-consensus earnings estimates.

Implications for Investors

Looking forward, Bernstein expects investors to debate Zillow's "monetization risk." The analyst also highlighted a key question regarding the appropriate valuation multiple for the stock as its revenue mix shifts from advertising toward mortgage origination.

The downgrade suggests a more cautious stance on Zillow's near-term growth prospects until there is clearer evidence of stabilization and re-acceleration in its core residential advertising business.

Read next

More on Stocks
Back to latest news

LATEST