Story

US Appeals Court Narrows NLRB Case Against Starbucks Over Unionization

ENTHMSVIIDZHZH-TWJAKOHI
Sep 4, 20262 min read
US Appeals Court Narrows NLRB Case Against Starbucks Over Unionization
Text size
Background

A U.S. federal appeals court has largely sided with Starbucks, overturning most of a National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) decision that found the company illegally threatened workers at a Kansas store for their unionization efforts. The ruling marks another legal development for the coffee giant in its ongoing disputes with organized labor.

Court Rejects Most NLRB Claims

In a 2-0 decision on Friday, the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected NLRB claims that Starbucks violated federal labor law at a store in Wichita, Kansas. The court found that statements from management about closing a hiring portal and reducing store hours due to union activities did not constitute illegal threats of reprisal.

Circuit Judge Stephen Higginson, writing for the court, reasoned that a hiring pause did not directly endanger the job security of current employees, and that reduced hours could be justified by understaffing. The court also found that a manager's comments acknowledging awareness of union discussions were not coercive or "out of the ordinary."

One Violation Upheld

While the ruling narrowed the scope of the NLRB's case, the court did uphold one key finding against the company. The panel agreed with the labor board that Starbucks had illegally threatened a pregnant employee's benefits.

Sample IUX Markets – In-articleAd

The court found there was "substantial evidence" that the employee could "reasonably feel" that her maternity leave benefits could be reduced if the store's workers voted to unionize. Both Starbucks and the NLRB did not immediately respond to requests for comment, according to Reuters.

Broader Context of Labor Disputes

This decision comes amid a widespread and contentious unionization campaign that has seen employees at more than 700 Starbucks stores vote to join unions. The drive has led to hundreds of complaints filed with the NLRB accusing the Seattle-based company of illegal anti-union practices.

This ruling also follows a separate, recent legal victory for Starbucks. A different federal appeals court in Manhattan reversed an NLRB finding that the company illegally barred workers from wearing union-supporting apparel. In that case, the court said the NLRB failed to properly balance the company's right to present its brand image with employees' right to organize.

Read next

More on Stocks
Back to latest news

LATEST