Seagate Stock Slides Despite Beating Earnings and Guidance Estimates

Seagate Technology (STX) shares fell sharply in morning trading, sliding 5.7% to $629.66 even after the data storage company posted a strong fiscal first-quarter earnings report and offered upbeat guidance. The decline appears to be driven by investors taking profits after a pre-earnings rally, coupled with downward revisions to analyst price targets.

A Beat-and-Raise Quarter

After Tuesday's market close, Seagate reported fiscal first-quarter results that exceeded analyst forecasts. The company's performance included:

• Non-GAAP EPS: $7.68, beating the consensus estimate of $7.39.
• Revenue: $4.23 billion, ahead of the expected $4.13 billion and representing a 61% increase year-over-year.

Management also issued a robust outlook for the second quarter, projecting revenue of approximately $4.8 billion and non-GAAP EPS of $9.20 at the midpoint. Both figures were well above prior Wall Street estimates, signaling continued business momentum.

Profit-Taking and Analyst Revisions

Ad

Despite the strong results, the stock's decline is being attributed to a "sell the news" dynamic, where investors lock in gains after a positive event. Seagate shares had already rallied 4.6% on Tuesday in anticipation of the strong report.

Adding to the pressure, several investment banks adjusted their outlooks. Morgan Stanley trimmed its price target on Seagate, citing concerns over slower-than-expected growth in hard drive shipment capacity and slightly reduced profit forecasts, though it maintained an Overweight rating on the stock. Susquehanna also revised its price target lower. Negative sentiment was further compounded by a recent insider sale from one of the company's executive vice presidents.

Market and Sector Context

The weakness in Seagate's stock appeared to be specific to the company and its direct competitor, Western Digital, which also traded lower. In contrast, memory chip manufacturers like Micron and SK Hynix advanced on separate catalysts, suggesting the sell-off was not a broader storage sector rout.

The broader market offered little support, with the S&P 500 and Nasdaq trading near flat as investors awaited the Federal Reserve's upcoming interest rate decision. While the day's trading activity reflects elevated expectations and profit-taking, the source noted that Seagate's underlying demand outlook remains strong, with nearline supply contracted through 2028.