Story

DAX Inclusion Fails to Boost Stock Performance, Deutsche Bank Finds

ENTHMSVIIDZHZH-TWJAKOHI
Aug 27, 20262 min read
DAX Inclusion Fails to Boost Stock Performance, Deutsche Bank Finds
Text size
Background

Inclusion in Germany's prestigious DAX index often leads to stock underperformance, contrary to common investor expectations, according to a new analysis by Deutsche Bank. The findings come as index provider STOXX prepares for its quarterly review on September 3.

A History of Underperformance

Looking at two decades of index history, Deutsche Bank analysts found a consistent pattern of underperformance for new entrants. The rally often happens *before* a company joins the index, followed by a period of weakness once the inclusion is official.

Key findings from the report include:

  • Pre-Inclusion Rally: Stocks outperformed the DAX by a median of 20% in the year leading up to their inclusion.
  • Post-Inclusion Slump: New members underperformed the DAX by a median of 8% in the year after joining. On the rebalancing day itself, they underperformed by a median of 2%.
  • Low Success Rate: Only 39% of new entrants (16 out of 41) managed to beat the index in their first year of membership.

The analysts, led by Carolin Raab, suggest this pattern is due to profit-taking after the shares have been bid up in anticipation of the event. "DAX inclusion is not as beneficial for stock price performance as one might expect," they wrote.

September Review in Focus

Sample IUX Markets – In-articleAd

The analysis is timely, with the next DAX rebalancing scheduled to be announced on September 3 and take effect on September 21. Deutsche Lufthansa AG is once again a candidate for re-entry, though the bank notes its prospects "have weakened in recent days" after a free-float increase at current member Fresenius Medical Care pushed it higher on the ranking list.

The outcome for Lufthansa will likely depend on share price movements before the August 31 data cut-off. If the airline does qualify, the two lowest-ranked current DAX members, Zalando and Scout24, would be at risk of demotion to the MDAX index.

The Liquidity Benefit

While stock performance tends to suffer, the one clear benefit of DAX membership is increased liquidity. The report found that trading volumes for companies joining the index rose by a median of 15%. Conversely, volumes for companies leaving fell by the same amount.

However, this liquidity does not translate into better returns for demoted stocks. The analysis showed that companies leaving the DAX had already underperformed by 33% in the year prior to exclusion and continued to underperform by another 14% in the year that followed. "While DAX inclusion helps in terms of liquidity, it is usually not a trigger for outperformance," the analysts concluded.

Read next

More on Stocks
Back to latest news

LATEST