Chewy Stock Slides After JPMorgan Downgrade Cites Weakening Consumer Trends

Shares of Chewy (NYSE: CHWY) fell in pre-market trading on Wednesday after JPMorgan downgraded the stock, highlighting concerns over slowing growth and weakening consumer spending on non-essential pet products. The stock slid 1.9% in pre-open trading, bucking a positive trend in the broader market.

JPMorgan Lowers Rating

JPMorgan cut its rating on Chewy to Neutral from a previous Overweight and slashed its price target to $24 from $29. The bank cited ongoing pressure on the company's organic growth due to macroeconomic headwinds.

In its note to clients, the investment bank pointed to "deteriorating discretionary and premiumization trends" in the pet retail sector. This suggests that consumers are becoming more cautious with their spending, potentially trading down from premium brands or cutting back on items like expensive treats and toys.

Post-Earnings Scrutiny

The downgrade follows Chewy's fiscal second-quarter earnings report on September 9. While the company met analyst expectations with adjusted earnings per share of $0.36 and slightly beat on revenue with $3.33 billion in net sales, the results have been characterized by analysts as a "low-quality" beat.

Ad

Wall Street's concerns stem from the drivers behind the results, which were attributed to one-time benefits rather than an acceleration in underlying demand. These factors reportedly included tariff refunds, gift card breakage, and a favorable timing shift in vendor rebates.

Broader Analyst Sentiment

JPMorgan's move is the latest in a series of cautious analyst actions following Chewy's earnings release. Several other firms, including RBC, TD Cowen, BofA, and Raymond James, have also trimmed their price targets on the stock.

Needham reiterated its Hold rating, noting that while the macro environment appeared to be stabilizing, discretionary categories remain challenged. In a counterpoint, Piper Sandler reaffirmed its Buy rating on Chewy on Wednesday, though the full-tier downgrade from JPMorgan appeared to carry more weight with investors. The stock's decline is company-specific, as the S&P 500, Dow Jones, and Nasdaq all traded higher.